MetaTrader 5 vs Sierra Chart

MetaTrader 5Package 3 (Base Standard)
BT Score
3.7Good
BT Score
3.8Good
Trustpilot
1.4Weak
Trustpilot
3.7Good

How the score is made

MetaTrader 5Sierra Chart
Execution3.92 market orders, 6 pending orders, 2 stop orders and Trailing Stop, netting and hedging position accounting, Market Depth and One Click Trading; of the four execution modes (Instant, Request, Market and Exchange) the brokerage company sets the mode for each financial security, and an order is a request to a broker.4.3Orders are entered from a Trade Window, the chart, the Chart DOM or a stand-alone Trade DOM with a long list of order types; server-side OCO and bracket orders are used where the trading service provides them, and Teton routes futures orders to CME, CBOT, NYMEX and COMEX with no transaction fee per contract but does not currently support options.
Value4.3The download page offers the desktop platform's trading functionality, technical and fundamental analysis, copy trading and automated trading for free, a web platform without installation and a mobile application that the mobile page offers for free; Market applications are bought or rented, signals are free or paid, and a virtual server is rented.4.2Five service packages are paid for 1, 3, 6 or 12 months, with discounts of 15%, 25% and 35% for the longer terms; delayed exchange data, historical data and a simulated trading service come with any package, while external services need an Integrated package and the TPO Chart study, Numbers Bars and the Market Depth Historical Graph need Package 5, 11 or 12.
Charting3.5Three chart types (broken line, sequence of bars and Japanese candlesticks), 21 timeframes from one minute to one month, chart templates and profiles, 38 technical indicators and 44 analytical objects; the platform page allows up to 100 open charts, while the technical analysis page speaks of an unlimited number of charts.4.4The features page lists over 400 customizable studies, bars based on seconds, minutes, number of trades, volume, price range, Renko or reversal values, draw types such as candlesticks, Kagi, Point and Figure and TPO profiles, and a complete set of drawing tools; the pricing page puts the TPO Chart study and Numbers Bars in Package 5, 11 or 12.
Automation4.4The MQL5 development environment creates, debugs, tests and optimizes trading robots; the Strategy Tester has every tick, 1 minute OHLC and open prices only modes, tests on multiple currencies, visual testing, optimization with genetic algorithms, forward testing and the MQL5 Cloud Network, and alerts notify by sound, email or push notification.4.3Trading systems are built in the built-in Excel-compatible spreadsheets or in C++ through the Advanced Custom Study Interface and Language, with tick by tick back-testing, chart replay with simulated trading and alert conditions that can send an e-mail; Sierra Chart says it does not provide programming help.
Data quality2.9Financial news from international news agencies and an economic calendar are built in, the technical analysis page lists 1-minute history and the platform has Market Depth; the iPhone app receives prices from brokers' servers, and the legal page says MetaQuotes Ltd neither provides nor offers data feed services.4.3The Denali feed provides real-time data, full market depth and market by order data for CME, CBOT, NYMEX, COMEX, EUREX, CFE, NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX, with exchange fees as an extra cost; any package streams delayed data, and historical daily data reaches back to 1970 for US commodity futures and 1-minute data at least to 2010.
Ease of use3.5Downloads for Windows, macOS and Linux, a web platform that needs no download or installation and works from any browser and operating system, an interface translated into 31 languages and a user manual; the markets page says a trader accesses the currency market through a forex broker.3.0The features page calls Sierra Chart a stand-alone program for Windows with native Mac OS and Linux support still being worked on, yet also says it runs on Windows, Linux or Mac OS; all program, data and configuration files install into one folder, any number of copies can run on a system, and the page advises a system with at least 6 cores.
Licensing and upselling3.6The download page offers the desktop platform's features for free, and the extras are named: Market applications are bought or rented, by most sellers for one to twelve months, each trading robot and indicator with a free demo version and beside free applications, signals are free or paid, and a virtual server is rented with a free trial of 24 hours.3.7The 21-day free trial has all software functions but no external services; packages renew from a prepaid balance, with no recurring card billing unless you set it up, and are cancelled by setting the package to Disabled; refunds cover only whole 31-day months less a processing fee, and exchange fees are not refunded.
Support3.0A user manual covers trading operations, charts, algorithmic trading, signals, the Market and virtual hosting, and it names two books on MQL5 programming and the MQL5.community website; the contacts page lists representative offices for sales inquiries, and the legal page gives a contact link for questions or comments.2.8Support runs through the online Support Board; e-mailed questions are delayed by 2 days or not answered, telephone and remote assistance are given at Sierra Chart's discretion, paying users get in general not more than 10 minutes of support per month, further support is billable, and trial users get help with account, pricing and basic questions.
Mobile3.9The application installs on iOS and Android smartphones and tablets and supports netting and hedging, Market Depth and all types of trade orders; the download page gives the iPhone and Android apps 30 indicators, 24 analytical objects, 3 chart types and 9 timeframes, against 38 indicators, 44 objects and 21 timeframes on the desktop.1.2Sierra Chart lists no phone or tablet app; its Teton order routing service has a web-based trading panel that can be used from any device, including mobile phones through a web browser, with order entry, target and stop orders, lists of current orders and positions and account balances.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
MetaTrader 5Sierra Chart
Price per year$0 (better)$202.80
BillingFreeYearly
TrialNot verified21 days
Quoted price$0$202.80 / 12 months
Market data pricingSome brokers sell certain market data by paid subscription; without it, data may be delayedReal-time exchange fees separate; availability depends on package

Key facts

MetaTrader 5Sierra Chart
PurposeCharting and tradingCharting and trading
Runs onmacOS · +5 moreWindows
External connectivityDirect connection to brokers' serversNot available on base packages
Data service accessNot verifiedsupport connectivity to Sierra Chart provided Data and Trading services only
Denali accessNot verifiedNot available on base packages
Standard feature scopeRich trading functionality, technical and fundamental market analysis, copy trading and automated tradingincludes all functionality of the software except what is listed in the Sierra Chart with Advanced Features section

Compare with