Phidias Propfirm vs UProfit

Soft
BT Score
3.3Fair
BT Score
3.1Fair
Trustpilot
No score on record
Trustpilot
3.4Fair

How the score is made

Phidias PropfirmUProfit
Evaluation rules4.1The comparison table lists low minimum trading days, no evaluation consistency rule, and distinct Express to Live, Fundamental and Premium paths.3.8Day Soft and Day Flex have one simulated evaluation stage with a single profit target, a 50% best-day rule that does not fail the account, and no time limit; the Soft and Flex pages let you advance after 2 days of successful trading, the Our way page names 4 successful trading days, and open positions are closed automatically at 4:10 PM ET each day.
Drawdown model4.0Phidias says Express to Live uses static drawdown and Fundamental/Premium use end-of-day trailing drawdown rather than intraday trailing drawdown.3.6In Day Soft and Day Flex the "Drawdown EOD" level is updated at the end of each day, stops rising at the starting balance, and puts the account in breach when it is touched at any time during the day; a paid reset recovers the account, in the evaluation also a free one after renewal, and in Virtual Live only within 10 days of the breach and at most 3 times.
Rule restrictions3.4The rules prohibit automated or HFT trading, lottery transactions, illiquid contracts, maturity spread trading, and some Treasury-bond arbitrage, while allowing news trading.2.8The mandatory best practices keep profits from winning trades held under 60 seconds below 20% of all winning-trade profits and trades of 10 seconds or less below 30% of all trades during the review period; a violation closes all accounts and cancels pending payouts.
Pricing fairness3.2The account page offers monthly and one-time payment options and says one-time payment includes zero fees after purchase, while monthly plans can involve activation fees.3.4Day Soft and Day Flex are monthly subscriptions with no activation fee; the programme page shows two prices for each account size, its help articles give the higher one as the subscription for the 50K, 100K and 150K sizes and the lower one for 10K, and all sales are final.
Profit split4.3Fundamental CASH accounts use 80% trader / 20% Phidias, while Premium progresses from 75% to 100% trader share from the fifth payout onward.4.0The Soft and Flex payout policies give the trader up to 90% of profits on each withdrawal and 10% to UProfit; the cap on a request is applied before the split.
Scaling programme3.5Fundamental and Premium traders may become eligible for LIVE after five successful payouts or $100,000 cumulative profits, but final approval is at Phidias risk management's sole discretion.2.6In Day Soft and Day Flex, scaling exists as contract steps in the 50K, 100K and 150K Virtual Live accounts and not in the 10K one; the account size does not increase, the account is closed after the sixth withdrawal, and the Live Account page also lists scaling contracts.
Payout reliability2.8Trustpilot shows the rating as unavailable due to a guideline breach, while sampled reviews include both a trader saying payouts totaled $4,000+ in under 24 hours and a one-star complaint about platform problems.2.5In Day Soft and Day Flex each payout needs 3 profit days, 40% consistency and a balance above a fixed threshold, is capped at 3% of the account size and limited to six per account, and a request is cancelled if the balance falls after it is made; the terms let UProfit judge a strategy non-viable at its sole discretion.
Firm safety2.3The terms identify Phidias Propfirm LTD and define CASH accounts as virtual currency accounts while LIVE accounts are funded with company money.2.7The terms describe the company as "a Limited Liability Company registered in Delaware"; no owners or managers are named, the footer and the privacy policy give different addresses, and the terms date from November 2021.
Transparency2.6Trustpilot states the company's rating is unavailable due to a breach of guidelines and says it removed a number of fake reviews.2.8The help centre documents rules, payout policy and reset prices for every Soft and Flex account size, but UProfit's pages disagree on prices, payout time and the company's address, the terms name another domain, and the footer's pass rate covers only the third quarter of 2024.
Execution quality3.1Phidias offers Rithmic, Tradovate and DeepCharts; Trustpilot also contains a one-star complaint alleging lag, popups and crashes on the trading platforms.2.9The platforms page names TradingView and Tradoverse on desktop and mobile and says they power UProfit's funded trading accounts, while the programme page calls the evaluation SIM and the Virtual Live account a demo; no data provider or broker is named.
Customer support3.4Sampled Trustpilot reviews praise fast human assistance, while the overall review page carries a platform-integrity warning.3.2Live chat runs Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM EST and email promises a reply within 24 hours, while the home page advertises 24/7 support.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
Phidias PropfirmUProfit
Cost to get fundedNot verified$130$130 first month + $0 activation fee
Entry feeNot verified$130
Activation feeNot verified$0
BillingNot verifiedmonthly
Advertised account sizeNot verified$50,000

Rules at a glance

Phidias PropfirmUProfit
Maximum lossNot verified$2,000
Evaluation stepsNot verified1 step
Daily loss limitNot verified$1,100
Drawdown typeNot verifiedOther
Profit target amountNot verified$3,000
Consistency rule pctNot verified50%
Max contractsNot verified3 contracts
Overnight holding policyNot verifiedSwing trading between sessions is not allowed.
InstrumentsNot verifiedCME, COMEX, and NYMEX

Payouts and fees

Phidias PropfirmUProfit
Profit splitNot verified90%
First payoutNot verified3 days · qualifying days
Payout buffer amountNot verified$2,500
Payout buffer conditionsNot verifiedWithdrawal Threshold: $52,500 (withdrawals only above this amount)
Payout cap conditionsNot verifiedPayout Cap: $1,500 (Payment to trader: $1,350 based on the split)
Payout consistency conditionsNot verifiedMake sure your best trading day is less than 40% of the total accumulated profit in the account.
Payout conditionsNot verifiedProfit Days: You must have accumulated at least 3 profit days for each withdrawal request. These days can be consecutive or non-consecutive.
Payout account limitNot verifiedMaximum 6 withdrawals per account. Upon completing the sixth withdrawal, the account will be closed.

Compare with