Phidias Propfirm vs Top One Futures

BT Score
3.3Fair
BT Score
3.5Good
Trustpilot
No score on record
Trustpilot
4.8Excellent

How the score is made

Phidias PropfirmTop One Futures
Evaluation rules4.1The comparison table lists low minimum trading days, no evaluation consistency rule, and distinct Express to Live, Fundamental and Premium paths.3.8Comparison page lists 1-Step Elite Challenge, instant funding options, profit targets, daily drawdown, consistency, minimum days, payout caps, and account limits.
Drawdown model4.0Phidias says Express to Live uses static drawdown and Fundamental/Premium use end-of-day trailing drawdown rather than intraday trailing drawdown.3.4Drawdown locks once profits reach total drawdown plus $100, and after first payout the trailing drawdown locks at starting balance plus $100.
Rule restrictions3.4The rules prohibit automated or HFT trading, lottery transactions, illiquid contracts, maturity spread trading, and some Treasury-bond arbitrage, while allowing news trading.2.5Prohibited practices include latency errors, hedging, a 10-second minimum trade rule, churning accounts, bots, copy trading, and strategies that risk broker relationships.
Pricing fairness3.2The account page offers monthly and one-time payment options and says one-time payment includes zero fees after purchase, while monthly plans can involve activation fees.3.5Homepage shows multiple account sizes, reset and activation fees, and both evaluation and instant simulated funded routes, but current pricing is promo-heavy and changes at checkout.
Profit split4.3Fundamental CASH accounts use 80% trader / 20% Phidias, while Premium progresses from 75% to 100% trader share from the fifth payout onward.4.3Help center says all sim funded accounts feature a 90/10 profit split and there is no current way to increase it further.
Scaling programme3.5Fundamental and Premium traders may become eligible for LIVE after five successful payouts or $100,000 cumulative profits, but final approval is at Phidias risk management's sole discretion.3.3Help center links a Path to Trading Live article and the site markets up to $1.5M in simulated funds, but live transition detail is less prominent than sim funding.
Payout reliability2.8Trustpilot shows the rating as unavailable due to a guideline breach, while sampled reviews include both a trader saying payouts totaled $4,000+ in under 24 hours and a one-star complaint about platform problems.4.0Homepage states '$26 Million+ in payouts', 'Less than 24h to payout', and shows PropFirmMatch verified payout total of $26,566,814.
Firm safety2.3The terms identify Phidias Propfirm LTD and define CASH accounts as virtual currency accounts while LIVE accounts are funded with company money.3.0Terms identify Top One Futures as a trade name of Top One Futures, LLC and state it operates independently from brokers with executions provided by broker partners.
Transparency2.6Trustpilot states the company's rating is unavailable due to a breach of guidelines and says it removed a number of fake reviews.3.4Help center publishes collections for general rules, account types, payouts, platform use, and restrictions, while terms reserve broad rights to modify rules and pricing.
Execution quality3.1Phidias offers Rithmic, Tradovate and DeepCharts; Trustpilot also contains a one-star complaint alleging lag, popups and crashes on the trading platforms.3.2Terms say all pricing and trade executions are provided by broker partners, while the homepage displays Tradovate, NinjaTrader Prop, and TradingView logos.
Customer support3.4Sampled Trustpilot reviews praise fast human assistance, while the overall review page carries a platform-integrity warning.4.4Trustpilot summary says customers consistently praise helpful, professional staff and quick resolution; recent reviews name support agents and company replies.

How we score

Compare with