Goat Funded Futures vs OneUp Trader

Standard
BT Score
3.2Fair
BT Score
3.2Fair
Trustpilot
2.0Weak
Trustpilot
4.7Excellent

How the score is made

Goat Funded FuturesOneUp Trader
Evaluation rules3.9EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Daily Payouts are one-phase evaluations with a 6% profit target and no time limit to pass; the evaluation consistency rule is 50% on EOD and Flex, 40% on Daily Payouts and none on 1-Day-Pass-Plan, and Instant Classic and Instant Lite have no evaluation.3.8The evaluation has one step: reach the profit target of the account, trade a minimum of 10 trading days (5 on the Pro Evaluation), close all positions by 3:15 PM CT, and have the three other best trading days sum to 80% or more of the largest day's net profit; the subscription renews every 30 days until the account is submitted for review or cancelled.
Drawdown model3.3EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan and Flex use an end-of-day trailing drawdown that locks at the starting balance, 4% on the 50K EOD account and 3% on its larger sizes; Daily Payouts trails end of day in the evaluation and intraday when funded, Instant Classic trails intraday at 5%, and daily loss limits differ by plan, with none by default on Flex.3.0The loss limit is a trailing drawdown; on a funded account it is calculated in real time, includes commissions and fees, and no longer changes once it reaches the initial starting balance. The plan list on the home page says "No Daily Loss Limit", while the FAQ on the same page lists "Adherence to the daily loss limit" among the rules for funded traders.
Rule restrictions2.4Positions are closed automatically at 15:55 CT and weekend holding is not permitted; funded accounts have a 2 minute buffer around high impact news, a 1 minute holding rule is checked at each payout request, 14 days without a trade breach the account, and bots are allowed on four plans but not on Daily Payouts and Instant Lite.2.7The funded trader rules require all positions to be closed prior to and during major economic releases, prohibit trading activities with a duration of less than 10 seconds and hedging across funded accounts, permit copy-trading only across accounts under the trader's own name, and demand a weekly trade count of no less than 50% of the evaluation average.
Pricing fairness3.8The billing article says all plans are a one-time fee with no monthly subscription and that only GOAT Access has an activation fee, paid after passing; evaluation accounts on EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Daily Payouts can be reset twice at a discounted price, and fees are non-refundable once the account has been provisioned.3.4The evaluation is a monthly subscription that renews every 30 days; the billing article splits the fee into a half at sign-up and a half charged as an activation fee on approval for funding, a rule violation can be cleared with a paid balance reset, and the terms make monthly payments nonrefundable. The home page offers a free test of 7 days.
Profit split3.6EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan and Flex pay 80/20 by default, and a 90/10 add-on costs an additional 20% of the challenge price; Daily Payouts and Instant Lite pay 90/10 from the first payout, Instant Classic pays 100% on the first 10,000 and then 90/10, and a 3% fee is applied to all payouts.4.2Funded traders keep 100% of their first 10,000 of profits and 90% of the net profits above the withdrawal profit threshold thereafter; a second or subsequent withdrawal in the same calendar week carries a 10% processing fee on the trader's profit share.
Scaling programme3.0A funded Flex account starts below its full contract limit and the limit goes up with simulated profit, on the 50K from 2 minis to 4; Daily Payouts and Instant Lite have full contract limits from day one, and a move to a live account has no public milestone and is decided by the risk team's review.2.6Funded traders must adhere to the Dynamic Scaling Targets: the number of contracts for the day is determined by the Cash On Hand value at the beginning of the trading session, and after a withdrawal the lot size is adjusted to the current account balance. The home page says that the funded account has the same size as the evaluation.
Payout reliability2.8EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Instant Classic pay in two request windows a month after 5 or 7 winning days, with caps by account size and a 50% withdrawal allowance on EOD, Flex and 1-Day-Pass-Plan; Daily Payouts allows one request every 24 hours, requests are processed within two business days, and a 3% fee is applied to all payouts.3.2Withdrawals need profits above the withdrawal threshold of the account size and a minimum transfer of 1,000 of the trader's profit share; one withdrawal per calendar week carries no processing fee. Bank wires are processed within 24 business hours once approved; cryptocurrency requests have a maximum per request and may take up to fourteen business days.
Firm safety3.0Goat Funded Futures is a trade name of WITI LIMITED (77146639), a company registered in Hong Kong, and its terms are governed by Hong Kong law; the company says it is not a financial broker and does not accept client deposits, funded accounts are simulated, and a live brokerage account follows only after the risk team's review.2.3The terms name the operator only as "OneUp Trader", state that "No live trading is provided directly by OneUp Trader" and set arbitration in Switzerland under the laws of Switzerland; OneUp Trader states no legal form, gives an address in Wilmington, Delaware, and places traders who pass with funding partners that it does not name.
Transparency3.1The help centre gives each plan's rules in dated articles, but the trading rules article says both that Daily Payouts has a 2 minute news buffer in the evaluation and that there are no news trading restrictions during an evaluation, and the plans overview lists a zero activation fee for all plans while the billing article gives GOAT Access one.2.5The help centre holds the rules for the evaluation and for funded accounts, but the home page says "No Daily Loss Limit" in its plan list and names a daily loss limit among the funded rules in its FAQ, and it promises "Hidden Fees - None!" while the help centre states an activation fee, balance reset fees and fees on withdrawals; no legal form is stated.
Execution quality3.7Platforms are NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView through Tradovate, TickBlaze, DeepCharts, ATAS, Quantower and TradeSea; trading commissions are built into the simulated environment and the home page lists a per-side fee for each instrument, and NinjaTrader and Tradovate are not available to residents of some countries.3.4The supported-platforms article lists NinjaTrader as the preferred platform, R|Trader and R|Trader Pro as free during the evaluation and when funded, and further platforms, among them Sierra Chart, Quantower and Bookmap; for funded traders the funding partners cover exchange data fees, and the total commissions include regulatory, platform and exchange fees.
Customer support3.3Support is available 24/7 by live chat and by email, with response times that may be slightly longer during peak US trading hours; there is a help centre and a Discord community, and no page gives a phone number.3.9The home page promises 24/7 customer service by phone, live chat and email and gives a phone number; help-centre articles link video tutorials in English, Spanish, Russian and French, and OneUp Trader does not state the languages of its support.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
Goat Funded FuturesOneUp Trader
Cost to get fundedNot verified$150$75 first month + $75 activation fee
Entry feeNot verified$75
Activation feeNot verified$75
BillingNot verifiedmonthly
Billing conditionsNot verifiedSubscriptions are charged monthly, starting from the sign-up date, and renew automatically every 30 days until you submit your account for review or cancel your account.
Advertised account sizeNot verified$50,000

Rules at a glance

Goat Funded FuturesOneUp Trader
Maximum lossNot verified$2,500 · trailing
Evaluation stepsNot verified1 step
Daily loss limitNot verifiedNone
Drawdown typeNot verifiedTrailing
Profit target amountNot verified$3,000
Max contractsNot verified6 contracts
PlatformsNot verifiedNinjaTrader
Market typeNot verifiedFutures

Payouts and fees

Goat Funded FuturesOneUp Trader
Profit splitNot verified90%
First payoutNot verifiedOn demand
Profit split conditionsNot verifiedFunded traders keep 100% of their first $10,000 of profits and 90% of the net profits above the withdrawal profit threshold thereafter.
Payout scheduleNot verifiedYou may request a withdrawal any time between Monday and Friday.
Payout buffer conditionsNot verified$50,000 Withdrawal Profit Threshold $2,500
Payout conditionsNot verifiedWithdrawal requests are subject to a minimum transfer amount of $1,000 of the trader's profit share.

Compare with