Blue Guardian Futures vs Goat Funded Futures

BT Score
3.2Fair
BT Score
3.2Fair
Trustpilot
3.6Good
Trustpilot
2.0Weak

How the score is made

Blue Guardian FuturesGoat Funded Futures
Evaluation rules4.0Zero, Elite and Reserve are one-phase evaluations and Direct has none; Elite has no minimum number of days, Zero has no time limit and no minimum number of trading days, and Zero and Reserve set a 6% profit target with a best-day consistency rule that delays passing without breaching the account.3.9EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Daily Payouts are one-phase evaluations with a 6% profit target and no time limit to pass; the evaluation consistency rule is 50% on EOD and Flex, 40% on Daily Payouts and none on 1-Day-Pass-Plan, and Instant Classic and Instant Lite have no evaluation.
Drawdown model3.8Elite, Reserve and Direct use an end-of-day trailing drawdown that does not follow unrealised profit during the day, and funded Zero accounts always use an intraday trailing one; on Direct and on funded Elite, Reserve and Zero accounts the limit stops trailing slightly above the starting balance, and hitting a daily loss limit is a soft breach.3.3EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan and Flex use an end-of-day trailing drawdown that locks at the starting balance, 4% on the 50K EOD account and 3% on its larger sizes; Daily Payouts trails end of day in the evaluation and intraday when funded, Instant Classic trails intraday at 5%, and daily loss limits differ by plan, with none by default on Flex.
Rule restrictions2.7On futures accounts, fully automated systems, hedging and martingale are not allowed, less than 50% of profit may come from trades held under 10 seconds, and a stop loss may be at most 5 times the profit target; news trading is allowed on Elite, Reserve and Direct accounts and, in Zero, on the evaluation only.2.4Positions are closed automatically at 15:55 CT and weekend holding is not permitted; funded accounts have a 2 minute buffer around high impact news, a 1 minute holding rule is checked at each payout request, 14 days without a trade breach the account, and bots are allowed on four plans but not on Daily Payouts and Instant Lite.
Pricing fairness3.6The Zero, Elite, Reserve and Direct articles describe a one-time purchase with no monthly or activation fees; a breached evaluation can be reset for a fee, a funded Elite or Reserve account that breaches before its first payout can be reactivated for a fee up to two times, funded Zero accounts cannot be reset, and the refund policy says all sales are final.3.8The billing article says all plans are a one-time fee with no monthly subscription and that only GOAT Access has an activation fee, paid after passing; evaluation accounts on EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Daily Payouts can be reset twice at a discounted price, and fees are non-refundable once the account has been provisioned.
Profit split3.8The payouts article gives all funded futures accounts a 90% profit split and charges a 3% processing fee on every payout; a Reserve request is limited to 50% of total profit, up to a cap.3.6EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan and Flex pay 80/20 by default, and a 90/10 add-on costs an additional 20% of the challenge price; Daily Payouts and Instant Lite pay 90/10 from the first payout, Instant Classic pays 100% on the first 10,000 and then 90/10, and a 3% fee is applied to all payouts.
Scaling programme2.5Elite and Direct do not use scaling; a funded Reserve limit starts lower, rises past profit triggers and may go down again, and Zero scales the same. The Path to Live article for Elite, Reserve and Direct leaves the Live offer to the Risk Team, the home page says of Reserve that 5 payouts lead to Live, and Zero offers Live after its maximum daily profit.3.0A funded Flex account starts below its full contract limit and the limit goes up with simulated profit, on the 50K from 2 minis to 4; Daily Payouts and Instant Lite have full contract limits from day one, and a move to a live account has no public milestone and is decided by the risk team's review.
Payout reliability2.8The payouts article says eligible requests are processed within 24 business hours; the futures page advertises 1-hour and 4-hour averages and a 24-hours payout guarantee; KYC is required before any payout, crypto is limited per request, Elite, Reserve and Direct cap each payout, and all payouts are subject to compliance, account rules and risk review.2.8EOD, 1-Day-Pass-Plan, Flex and Instant Classic pay in two request windows a month after 5 or 7 winning days, with caps by account size and a 50% withdrawal allowance on EOD, Flex and 1-Day-Pass-Plan; Daily Payouts allows one request every 24 hours, requests are processed within two business days, and a 3% fee is applied to all payouts.
Firm safety2.6The terms name Iconic Exchange FZCO t/a Blue Guardian as operator of the site, and the footer names Blue Guardian Limited in Saint Lucia as provider of the platforms for simulated trading; the footer calls all trading notional trading on a demo account and says the company is not a licensed investment services provider within the meaning of MiFID II.3.0Goat Funded Futures is a trade name of WITI LIMITED (77146639), a company registered in Hong Kong, and its terms are governed by Hong Kong law; the company says it is not a financial broker and does not accept client deposits, funded accounts are simulated, and a live brokerage account follows only after the risk team's review.
Transparency2.9The help centre holds rules articles for Zero, Elite, Reserve, Direct and Express and a table of costs per side; the futures page and the payouts article give different payout times, and the terms and the footer write the Dubai address of Iconic Exchange FZCO differently.3.1The help centre gives each plan's rules in dated articles, but the trading rules article says both that Daily Payouts has a 2 minute news buffer in the evaluation and that there are no news trading restrictions during an evaluation, and the plans overview lists a zero activation fee for all plans while the billing article gives GOAT Access one.
Execution quality3.5All new futures accounts use Tradovate, with NinjaTrader and TradingView, and the Zero article says Zero is available on NinjaTrader; the instruments article lists the futures contracts with a total cost per side, and the prohibited-strategies article speaks of a simulated market's lack of slippage.3.7Platforms are NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView through Tradovate, TickBlaze, DeepCharts, ATAS, Quantower and TradeSea; trading commissions are built into the simulated environment and the home page lists a per-side fee for each instrument, and NinjaTrader and Tradovate are not available to residents of some countries.
Customer support3.3The futures page advertises 24/7 support via ticket and email, the payouts article points to live chat, the refund policy gives a support email address, and the help centre is offered in English, French, Hindi, Italian and Spanish.3.3Support is available 24/7 by live chat and by email, with response times that may be slightly longer during peak US trading hours; there is a help centre and a Discord community, and no page gives a phone number.

How we score

Compare with