CMC MarketsTickmill
Trading costsFX Active gives EUR/USD and five other majors 0.0 minimum spreads for a 0.0025% commission and other pairs 25% lower spreads, standard MT4 accounts currently pay no commission, share CFD commission depends on the country, and dormant accounts pay a monthly fee.Classic has spreads from 1.6 pips with no commission, while Raw starts from 0.0 pips plus a commission per lot per side on forex and metals, a little higher on TradingView Raw; swaps are charged nightly and triple on Wednesday outside swap-free Islamic accounts, long crypto positions pay 10% a year, and a dormant client area pays a quarterly inactivity fee.
Regulation and client protectionCMC Markets Bermuda Limited is licensed by the Bermuda Monetary Authority, keeps retail client money segregated with FCA-regulated UK banks and reconciles it daily, and its FAQ gives retail clients negative balance protection, but no page names a compensation scheme.Tickmill Ltd is a Securities Dealer under the Seychelles FSA (licence SD008) with segregated client money; the help centre promises negative balance protection to all clients, while the client agreement makes clients liable for any deficit, and a compensation scheme is named only for Tickmill UK and Tickmill Europe clients.
Platforms and toolsClients choose MT4, MT5, TradingView or the CMC web platform and app with a pattern scanner, client sentiment and Morningstar and Reuters content; MetaTrader brings Expert Advisors and hedging, but an MT4 account gives no access to Next Generation or TradingView.Classic and Raw accounts work on MetaTrader 4 and 5 across desktop, web and mobile with Expert Advisors allowed, TradingView Raw trades through TradingView and the Tickmill Trader app, and MT5 offers copy trading and signals; cTrader is not among the platforms.
Leverage and marginThe FAQ gives retail clients up to 200:1 (0.5% margin) while the forex page puts forex margin from 3.34%; MetaTrader trades may be closed without notice below 50% of margin unless agreed otherwise, and no close-out level is stated for Next Generation.Tickmill Ltd offers up to 1:1000 through dynamic leverage on MT5 and Tickmill Trader (the leverage page adds TradingView), falling as positions grow, and up to 1:500 on MT4; the tiers and their margin rates are published, but no margin call or stop-out level is stated, and the agreement lets Tickmill Ltd close all trades when margin runs short.
ExecutionCMC Markets claims no dealer intervention and 99.29% of MT4 market open orders filled at quote, while its pricing policy lets the trading desk adjust prices for market-making; it gives MT4 execution as a 0.018 second median on the home page and 0.066 seconds on its platforms page, and executed prices can differ either way.Under its client agreement Tickmill Ltd deals as principal, may act as market maker on forex and CFDs and may hold positions against clients; the site claims 0.15-second average execution, the about page no requotes, and the Best Execution Policy the agreement cites is not on Tickmill Ltd's list of legal documents.
Deposits and withdrawalsThere is no minimum deposit and currently no deposit or withdrawal fee from CMC Markets; cards, bank transfer, Binance Pay, Neteller and Skrill are named, but no page states how long a withdrawal takes.The payments page names bank wire, card, crypto, Skrill, Neteller and UnionPay, and its tables show no Tickmill commission either way, withdrawal processing within one working day and arrival instantly or within up to eight working days, but the agreement reserves a withdrawal commission of up to 5.2% after too little trading.
Support and transparencyThe contact page offers phone and email, but the pages give support hours as 8am to 8pm, 24 hours on weekdays or Sunday night to Friday night, complaints are handled in English only, and the pages disagree on leverage, instrument counts and MT4 speed.The contact page gives support 24/5, phone on weekdays from 7:00 to 16:00 GMT and an AI chat around the clock, the payments page 07:00 to 20:00 GMT on weekdays for payment questions; pages disagree on negative balance protection, hedging, the FSCS currency and the instrument count, and the legal documents page lacks two documents the agreement cites.
MarketsHeadlines offer up to 21,000 instruments while footnotes give about 12,000 on Next Generation, 2,220 on MT5 and 220 on MT4, with forex pairs given as up to 300, 300 or more than 300, plus indices, commodities, shares, ETFs, crypto, share baskets, forex and commodity indices, rates and bonds.The home page lists 60+ currency pairs, precious metals and energies, Bitcoin, Ethereum and more, 20+ indices and 500+ stocks and ETFs, the Raw account page adds bonds, and the about page claims access to 180+ instruments; futures and options are offered under Tickmill UK Ltd.