BlackBull Markets vs Tickmill

ECN Prime accountEurope · Classic
BT Score
3.3Fair
BT Score
3.2Fair
Trustpilot
4.7Excellent
Trustpilot
2.2Weak

How the score is made

BlackBull MarketsTickmill
Trading costs3.6ECN Standard charges no commission on spreads from 0.8 pips and ECN Prime a commission per lot per side from 0.0 pips, while a second set of accounts lists Standard from 1.4, Raw from 0.0 with commission and Pro from 0.6; there is no inactivity fee, and swap-free accounts carry administrative fees.3.6Classic has spreads from 1.6 pips with no commission, while Raw starts from 0.0 pips plus a commission per lot per side on forex and metals, a little higher on TradingView Raw; swaps are charged nightly and triple on Wednesday outside swap-free Islamic accounts, long crypto positions pay 10% a year, and a dormant client area pays a quarterly inactivity fee.
Regulation and client protection2.6The entity article serves eligible clients outside New Zealand through BBG Limited, regulated by the Seychelles FSA under SD045, and New Zealand clients mainly through Black Bull Group Limited, an FMA-licensed derivatives issuer; a support article on the New Zealand provider puts client funds at ANZ Bank, and no compensation scheme is named.2.9Tickmill Ltd is a Securities Dealer under the Seychelles FSA (licence SD008) with segregated client money; the help centre promises negative balance protection to all clients, while the client agreement makes clients liable for any deficit, and a compensation scheme is named only for Tickmill UK and Tickmill Europe clients.
Platforms and tools4.3MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader and TradingView come with any account type, on Windows, Mac, Android, iOS and the browser, along with BlackBull CopyTrader for copying or leading trades and BlackBull Invest for share investing; a free VPS goes to clients who trade 20 lots of forex or metals a month.4.1Classic and Raw accounts work on MetaTrader 4 and 5 across desktop, web and mobile with Expert Advisors allowed, TradingView Raw trades through TradingView and the Tickmill Trader app, and MT5 offers copy trading and signals; cTrader is not among the platforms.
Leverage and margin2.8Leverage reaches 1:500, with limits that may differ by residence, temporary cuts around major data releases and rollover and tiered leverage on Bitcoin, but the pages disagree on the margin levels: the support articles give a margin call at 70% and a stop-out at 50%, while one of the two account tables gives 50% and 20%.3.1Tickmill Ltd offers up to 1:1000 through dynamic leverage on MT5 and Tickmill Trader (the leverage page adds TradingView), falling as positions grow, and up to 1:500 on MT4; the tiers and their margin rates are published, but no margin call or stop-out level is stated, and the agreement lets Tickmill Ltd close all trades when margin runs short.
Execution3.3BlackBull calls itself a strictly non-dealing desk broker offering ECN accounts and straight-through processing, does no re-quotes and says slippage can go either way in busy periods; its servers are at Equinix LD5 in London, and average execution is given as under 60ms on the home page and under 100ms on other pages.2.5Under its client agreement Tickmill Ltd deals as principal, may act as market maker on forex and CFDs and may hold positions against clients; the site claims 0.15-second average execution, the about page no requotes, and the Best Execution Policy the agreement cites is not on Tickmill Ltd's list of legal documents.
Deposits and withdrawals2.7Deposits are free with no minimum beyond each method's own, and most are instant on approval, but the withdrawal table puts a flat fee on every method except one Australian bank transfer, card, Apple Pay and Google Pay withdrawals are capped at the amount deposited, and the page lists method minimums while saying there is no minimum withdrawal.3.3The payments page names bank wire, card, crypto, Skrill, Neteller and UnionPay, and its tables show no Tickmill commission either way, withdrawal processing within one working day and arrival instantly or within up to eight working days, but the agreement reserves a withdrawal commission of up to 5.2% after too little trading.
Support and transparency2.8Support runs 24/7 by live chat, phone, e-mail and WhatsApp, but the pages contradict each other on margin levels, execution speed, the Prime+ commission, minimum deposits and withdrawals, and on whether clients outside New Zealand are served at all.2.2The contact page gives support 24/5, phone on weekdays from 7:00 to 16:00 GMT and an AI chat around the clock, the payments page 07:00 to 20:00 GMT on weekdays for payment questions; pages disagree on negative balance protection, hedging, the FSCS currency and the instrument count, and the legal documents page lacks two documents the agreement cites.
Markets3.8The markets page lists 91 currency pairs with indices, stocks, metals, crypto and commodities, while other pages give 90+ and 70+ pairs; the headline count of 26,000+ instruments is also the figure given for the shares, options, ETFs and bonds of BlackBull Invest.3.5The home page lists 60+ currency pairs, precious metals and energies, Bitcoin, Ethereum and more, 20+ indices and 500+ stocks and ETFs, the Raw account page adds bonds, and the about page claims access to 180+ instruments; futures and options are offered under Tickmill UK Ltd.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
BlackBull MarketsTickmill
Cost of one standard tradeNot verifiedNot verified
Advertised minimum spread0 pips1.6 pips
Commission modelNot verifiedcommission free
Commission per lot per side$3Not verified
Commission termsCommission is calculated at US$3 per lot per side.Not verified
Funding termsNot verifiedSpecify your deposit amount (minimum 100 USD for all account types) and complete the transaction through your chosen payment provider.

Key facts

BlackBull MarketsTickmill
PlatformTradingView · +3 moreMT4 and MT5
JurisdictionNew ZealandCyprus
Max. leverage1:5001:30
Min. deposit$0$100
Account typeECN PrimeClassic
Account currenciesNot verifiedUSD, EUR, GBP, PLN, CHF
EntityBlack Bull Group LimitedTickmill Europe Ltd
Professional maximum leverageNot verified1:500
Minimum trade sizeNot verified0.01 lots

Compare with