CMC Markets vs IG

UK · Standard CFDUK · CFD
BT Score
3.3Fair
BT Score
3.5Good
Trustpilot
4.3Great
Trustpilot
3.7Good

How the score is made

CMC MarketsIG
Trading costs3.3FX Active gives EUR/USD and five other majors 0.0 minimum spreads for a 0.0025% commission and other pairs 25% lower spreads, standard MT4 accounts currently pay no commission, share CFD commission depends on the country, and dormant accounts pay a monthly fee.3.5The forex page charges no commission on forex CFDs, EUR/USD has a 0.6 minimum spread and averages of 0.86 and 1.13 measured in 2020, forex overnight funding includes IG's 0.8% yearly charge, other currencies cost a 1.0% conversion charge, and IG International's charges page names no inactivity fee.
Regulation and client protection3.1CMC Markets Bermuda Limited is licensed by the Bermuda Monetary Authority, keeps retail client money segregated with FCA-regulated UK banks and reconciles it daily, and its FAQ gives retail clients negative balance protection, but no page names a compensation scheme.3.0IG International Limited is licensed by the Bermuda Monetary Authority without a stated licence number; retail client money sits in segregated trust accounts, negative balance protection covers trading debt for non-professionals only, and no compensation scheme is named for this company.
Platforms and tools4.1Clients choose MT4, MT5, TradingView or the CMC web platform and app with a pattern scanner, client sentiment and Morningstar and Reuters content; MetaTrader brings Expert Advisors and hedging, but an MT4 account gives no access to Next Generation or TradingView.4.0Besides its own web platform and app, IG offers TradingView, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, ProRealTime and L2 Dealer, with alerts, third-party signals, guaranteed stops, APIs, algorithmic trading and direct market access for eligible traders.
Leverage and margin2.6The FAQ gives retail clients up to 200:1 (0.5% margin) while the forex page puts forex margin from 3.34%; MetaTrader trades may be closed without notice below 50% of margin unless agreed otherwise, and no close-out level is stated for Next Generation.3.4IG states margin rather than leverage, 0.50% on EUR/USD in its forex table, and explains margin call clearly: it aims to email at 99% and 75% of margin and to start closing at 50%, may close earlier and need not warn you.
Execution3.1CMC Markets claims no dealer intervention and 99.29% of MT4 market open orders filled at quote, while its pricing policy lets the trading desk adjust prices for market-making; it gives MT4 execution as a 0.018 second median on the home page and 0.066 seconds on its platforms page, and executed prices can differ either way.3.3On IG Group data for April to June 2024 IG reports 98.97% of orders filled and all filled orders at the requested price or better, though its slippage table shows negative slippage on some stops; limit and at-quote orders fill at that price or better or are rejected, and IG passes on positive slippage.
Deposits and withdrawals3.2There is no minimum deposit and currently no deposit or withdrawal fee from CMC Markets; cards, bank transfer, Binance Pay, Neteller and Skrill are named, but no page states how long a withdrawal takes.3.0The funding page lists debit cards and bank transfers as free and credit cards at 1% or 0.5%, the charges page a 2.3% card processor charge; card withdrawals typically take two to five bank working days and bank transfers can take one to three, with a daily cap on cards.
Support and transparency2.5The contact page offers phone and email, but the pages give support hours as 8am to 8pm, 24 hours on weekdays or Sunday night to Friday night, complaints are handled in English only, and the pages disagree on leverage, instrument counts and MT4 speed.3.4The contact page offers secure messaging and WhatsApp 24 hours a day except a Saturday window, which the forex page calls 24/7, the home page adds web chat and a help article a phone line; cost pages are detailed, but pages disagree on the FTSE index, market and client counts, and card and guaranteed stop charges.
Markets4.2Headlines offer up to 21,000 instruments while footnotes give about 12,000 on Next Generation, 2,220 on MT5 and 220 on MT4, with forex pairs given as up to 300, 300 or more than 300, plus indices, commodities, shares, ETFs, crypto, share baskets, forex and commodity indices, rates and bonds.4.5IG lists more than 17,000 markets (18,000+ on its forex page): 90+ forex pairs, 80+ indices, 13,000+ or 16,000+ shares by page, commodities, eight cryptocurrencies and 5,400+ ETFs, plus bonds, rates, options, baskets, futures, knock-out and volatility CFDs and weekend markets.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
CMC MarketsIG
Cost of one standard tradeNot verifiedNot verified
Advertised eurusd minimum ptsNot verified0.6 provider pts
Spread model0.2 pointsNot verified
Commission modelNot verifiedspread pricing
Commission termsYES (Shares & ETFs only) - No commission on UK & European share & ETF CFDs; US share & ETF CFDs from $10For Indices, Commodities, and Forex trading, we charge a spread, which depends on underlying market conditions and built into the price shown when submitting a trade – so what you see is what you pay.
Deposit fee termsNot verifiedDebit card: free Credit card: free
Funding termsHowever, you won't be able to place a trade until there are sufficient funds to cover your position.Not verified
Overnight fee termsNot verifiedIG admin fee 1% for FX and 3% for other asset classes
Holding cost termsYESNot verified
Fx conversion fee pctNot verified0.8%
Inactivity fee$13.23Not verified
Inactivity terms£10 monthly, if no trading activity for one year. No fee on accounts with zero funds.Not verified

Key facts

CMC MarketsIG
PlatformCMC web platform · +1 moreIG web platform · +1 more
JurisdictionUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom
Max. leverage1:301:30
Min. depositNo minimum$334.40
Account typeCFDCFD
Account currenciesGBP, EUR, USD, AUS, CAD, NOK, NZD, PLN, SEK, SGDNot verified
Platform optionsTrade via our web platform, iOS or Android app, or MetaTrader 4Not verified
Demo accountYesNot verified
EntityCMC Markets UK plcIG Markets Ltd
Negative balance protectionYesNot verified
Professional maximum leverageNot verified1:222
Forex margin pctNot verified3.33%
Instrument count21000 instrumentsNot verified
Forex pair count300 pairsNot verified
HedgingYesNot verified
Guaranteed stop premiumYES (100% refund if not triggered)Not verified
Market data feesYES (applies to shares on certain countries)Not verified

Compare with