TradeDay vs Tradeify

Fast Pass $25,000Select $25,000
BT Score
3.9Good
BT Score
4.0Great
Trustpilot
4.6Excellent
Trustpilot
4.6Excellent

How the score is made

TradeDayTradeify
Evaluation rules4.2Quick Pay requires a minimum of 5 trading days, reaching the profit target, and no day greater than 30% of total profits; Fast Pass has no minimum trading days and a 45% consistency cap.4.0Tradeify offers Growth Evaluation, Select Evaluation, and Lightning Funded accounts, with Select offering no daily loss limit during evaluation and Lightning skipping evaluation entirely.
Drawdown model3.8The homepage pricing table offers intraday and end-of-day drawdown choices, with the 50k intraday account showing a '$2,000' trailing max drawdown calculated intraday.4.0Tradeify states that all accounts use 'End-of-Day (EOD) trailing drawdown,' but that the limit is 'ENFORCED in real-time.'
Rule restrictions4.1TradeDay says it has 'just one rule - Don't break the Maximum Drawdown Limit' plus guidelines for times, products, and position limits, with accidental guideline breaches not automatically failing a trader.3.6Tradeify applies consistency rules: Growth Sim Funded accounts follow 35%, Select Evaluation accounts 40% during evaluation, and Lightning Funded accounts use a gradual 20% to 30% rule.
Pricing fairness4.0The pricing cards state 'No activation fee' and list reset costs, but the legal footer says subscription fees are non-refundable except where required by law.4.3The pricing reference says 'All plans are one-time purchases with no recurring billing.'
Profit split4.0The support knowledge base has a dedicated 'Payout Policy' folder, including Quick Pay Funded Sim payout policy and withdrawal process articles; full split details were not visible in the snapshot reviewed.4.2For Select Flex, Tradeify states 'Profit Split: 90 Trader / 10 Tradeify.'
Scaling programme3.2TradeDay says it has funded thousands of traders and introduced multiple account types and drawdown structures, but a clearly documented long-term scaling ladder was not found during this pass.4.0Tradeify 3.0 describes an Elite Live reward model with a Performance Reward Pool and says Select traders can qualify for a 1.5x multiplier by meeting discipline criteria.
Payout reliability4.2TradeDay states it has made '$10M+ Verified Payouts' and shows payout certificates on its homepage.4.1Trustpilot's recent-review summary says many reviewers praise a 'smooth and efficient payout process, with funds often received quickly and without complications.'
Firm safety3.8TradeDay says it was founded in 2020 by James Thorpe and Steve Miley, lists staff biographies, and gives a Chicago address; its footer also discloses that TradeDay LLC is not registered with the SEC or CFTC.3.4The agreement names 'Tradeify Holdings, Corp. and its affiliates' and states that account funds are company property and 'exclusively demo funds unless otherwise stated.'
Transparency4.3The site publishes founders, staff, address, pass-rate disclosure, refund policy, registration disclaimer, objectives, rules, and drawdown model in public pages and support articles.4.1The Help Center publishes separate articles for pricing, account types, consistency, trailing drawdown, daily loss limits, restricted countries, news trading, and payouts.
Execution quality3.5TradeDay's knowledge base includes platform setup articles for Tradovate and NinjaTrader, but public execution-quality evidence such as slippage statistics was not found during this pass.3.7The supported-products article says Tradeify supports instruments from CME, COMEX, NYMEX, and CBOT, with additional EUREX subscriptions for some products.
Customer support4.0TradeDay runs a public Freshdesk knowledge base with support ticket submission and states support is available 24/7 in the site footer.4.4Trustpilot's review summary says customers 'consistently praise the excellent customer service and responsive staff.'

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
TradeDayTradeify
Cost to get funded$130$109 (better)
Entry fee$130$109
Activation fee policyNot verifiedNone
Conditional offer fee$65Not verified
Billingmonthlyone time
Advertised account size$25,000$25,000

Rules at a glance

TradeDayTradeify
Maximum loss$1,000 · end of day$1,000 · end of day
Evaluation stepsNot verified1 step
Daily loss limitNot verifiedNone
Drawdown typeTrailing · end of dayTrailing · end of day
Profit target amount$1,500$1,500
Consistency rule pct45%40%
Minimum trading days3 trading daysNot verified
PlatformsTradovateNot verified

Payouts and fees

TradeDayTradeify
Profit split80%90% (better)
First payout5 days · qualifying days5 days · qualifying days
Profit split conditions80/20 Funded Sim, 90/10 Funded LiveNot verified
Winning day conditionsNot verified25K account: $100 minimum profit per day.
Payout cap conditionsNot verified25K account: up to 50% of total profits, capped at $1,250 per payout.
Payout conditionsConsistency: 45% Min Days to Payout: 5 Min Profitable Days: 5 x $100 Min Payout Request: $250 Max Payout Request Per Cycle: $750The official policy says Select Flex uses a 90/10 split, pays every 5 winning days, has no daily loss limit, and has no consistency rule. Instead of a minimum balance requirement, traders need to meet the account-specific winning-day profit thresholds.

Compare with