Phidias Propfirm vs TradeDay

Fast Pass $25,000
BT Score
3.4Fair
BT Score
3.5Good
Trustpilot
3.1Fair
Trustpilot
4.6Excellent

How the score is made

Phidias PropfirmTradeDay
Evaluation rules3.9Each account type has one evaluation phase with a profit target; the terms require 0 trading days on Express to Live, 1 on Premium and 3 on Fundamental. A failed evaluation continues after a paid reset or an automatic reset after 30 days, the terms allow no reset on Express to Live, and a passed account is audited within 24 to 72 business hours.3.8The evaluation has three objectives and one failing rule, the maximum drawdown: Quick Pay asks for a minimum of 5 trading days and no day above 30% of total profits, Fast Pass for 3 minimum trading days and no day above 45%; the home page says Fast Pass has no minimum trading day requirement, and the terms name a minimum 7-day period.
Drawdown model3.8Express to Live uses a static drawdown that never trails and has no daily loss limit. Fundamental and Premium use a trailing drawdown calculated at the end of each trading day; it stays until the end of the evaluation and stops just above the starting balance on funded 50K and 100K accounts. The account is liquidated when the balance reaches the limit.3.4The maximum drawdown is an end-of-day or an intraday trailing limit, enforced in real time, and it trails account growth until it reaches the starting balance; all Quick Pay Funded Sim accounts have an intraday drawdown regardless of the evaluation's, and all Fast Pass Funded Sim accounts have end-of-day drawdowns.
Rule restrictions3.0News trading is authorised on all accounts, and copy trading is allowed within the account limits. Robots and fully automated trading are not permitted, Fundamental and Express to Live positions must be closed before the end of the day while Premium may hold overnight, and funded Fundamental and Premium accounts have a 30% consistency rule.3.2Day trading only; the prohibited practices include bots or automated systems bought from a third party, strategies that produce more than 200 trades in a day, order splitting, hedging between accounts and a VPN or VPS that masks the location; funded traders may not trade within 2% of a price limit, and profits from prohibited practices are confiscated.
Pricing fairness3.4An evaluation is paid monthly, with an activation fee after a pass, or once, with no activation fee and no recurring billing. The terms say all subscriptions are final, with no returns, refunds or exchanges, and allow no reset on Express to Live evaluations; a liquidated Premium funded account can be reset once, for a fee, within 24 hours.3.6The home page's account cards show a one-time fee with "No Subscription Required" and "No activation fee"; the terms describe a paid reset or an automatic reset with the next subscription payment, and the refund policy in the help centre says no refund can be offered after purchase, except the last payment of a forgotten membership.
Profit split3.9Express to Live and Fundamental accounts pay the trader a fixed 80%. Premium funded accounts pay 75% on the first payout and rise with each payout to 100% from the fifth, and the terms fix the split on a LIVE account at 80%, whatever level the funded account had reached.3.0Quick Pay Funded Sim pays 50/50 while the account's profit is below a fixed threshold and 80/20 above it, worked out per account; the home page's cards give Fast Pass 80/20 in Funded Sim and both account types 90/10 in Funded Live.
Scaling programme3.3Each account size has its own contract limit, and growth runs through the LIVE account: Express to Live converts when its funded target is reached, Fundamental and Premium become eligible after 5 payouts or a cumulative profit threshold and Phidias decides at its sole discretion, while the About page still promises the upgrade after 3 payouts.2.5The Fast Pass cards start the Funded Sim position limit below the evaluation's, 2 contracts against 5 on the 50k account, and add 1 contract per fixed step of profit at end of day; the Quick Pay cards show the same position limit as in the evaluation and "Milestones: None".
Payout reliability3.1A Fundamental account can request a payout every 10 trading days and a Premium account every 5, above a balance threshold and up to a cap per period; the rules page and the terms give different minimum withdrawals. Payouts go to the Phidias Wallet and from there to Rise, and the site says 90% are processed in under 30 minutes.3.9The Quick Pay policy sets a minimum request and aims to process requests by the next business day, through Riseworks; the home page's cards give Quick Pay no payout buffer and 1 minimum day to payout, and Fast Pass 5 days, minimum profitable days and a maximum request per cycle; a help article modified in June 2025 asks traders to clear a Buffer Zone first.
Firm safety3.3The contact page names Phidias Propfirm Limited, registration number GICO.123937-76, in Eurotowers, Gibraltar; the terms are governed by Gibraltar law, with the French text authoritative. The terms define a CASH account as a virtual currency account and a LIVE account as funded with real money; the home page says Dorman Trading clears LIVE trades.3.9Tradeday LLC gives a Chicago address and names its founders, James Thorpe and Steve Miley, and further staff; the help centre says it was established in 2020 and is registered in Illinois; the firm says it is not registered with the SEC or CFTC, and its terms define the Funded SIM Account as simulated and the Funded LIVE Account as funded by TradeDay.
Transparency2.7One rules page holds the rule set of each account type and the commission per instrument, but it disagrees with the terms on the minimum withdrawal and on how many 150K Express to Live accounts a trader may hold, the About page still gives LIVE thresholds that the rules page calls deprecated, and only the French text of the terms is authoritative.2.9Rules, the commission per product, the Quick Pay payout policy and a pass rate of 36% are public, but the pages disagree: the terms name a minimum 7-day period, a subscription payment and a paid reset, the home page says "No subscriptions" and 5 or 3 minimum trading days, and the payout policy gives its cut-off once in ET and once in CT.
Execution quality3.6Accounts run on DeepCharts with dxFeed, on a Rithmic-compatible platform or on NinjaTrader or Tradovate, and the Tradovate page says an existing account cannot switch platform. The rules page lists the commission per side for each instrument by broker and data feed; Rithmic market depth is a paid add-on.3.9Tradovate and NinjaTrader come with a free licence, TradingView and Jigsaw need the trader's own, and the Rithmic list includes R|Trader Pro, ATAS, Quantower and Sierra Chart; NinjaTrader Desktop is not supported with Rithmic accounts; commissions are published per product and side, and TradeDay adds none on top of its broker's.
Customer support3.1Support works through tickets, and the site links a Discord community and a help centre; the home page promises a response in under 15 minutes in English, French and Spanish. Support hours are not published.3.6Support is by live chat on the website and by e-mail; the website's footer says "Available 24/7", the help centre has a ticket form and the languages English, French, Portuguese and Spanish, and the About page names a Head of Trader Support.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
Phidias PropfirmTradeDay
Cost to get fundedNot verified$130
Entry feeNot verified$130
Conditional offer feeNot verified$65
BillingNot verifiedmonthly
Advertised account sizeNot verified$25,000

Rules at a glance

Phidias PropfirmTradeDay
Maximum lossNot verified$1,000 · end of day
Evaluation stepsNot verifiedNot verified
Daily loss limitNot verifiedNot verified
Drawdown typeNot verifiedTrailing · end of day
Profit target amountNot verified$1,500
Consistency rule pctNot verified45%
Minimum trading daysNot verified3 trading days
PlatformsNot verifiedTradovate

Payouts and fees

Phidias PropfirmTradeDay
Profit splitNot verified80%
First payoutNot verified5 days · qualifying days
Profit split conditionsNot verified80/20 Funded Sim, 90/10 Funded Live
Payout conditionsNot verifiedConsistency: 45% Min Days to Payout: 5 Min Profitable Days: 5 x $100 Min Payout Request: $250 Max Payout Request Per Cycle: $750

Compare with