Blue Guardian vs Maven Trading

2-Step Standard $100,000Maven Standard Two Step $5,000
BT Score
2.7Weak
BT Score
2.7Weak
Trustpilot
3.0Fair
Trustpilot
3.8Good

How the score is made

Blue GuardianMaven Trading
Evaluation rules3.7The plan articles give 2 Step Standard 8% and then 4% and 1 Step Standard 9%, each with 3 days of at least 0.5% profit, 1 Step Nano 10% with a 50% consistency rule and 2 Step Nano 8% and then 5%, both without minimum days to pass; the forex page says there are no time limits.3.8Standard 2 Step asks for 8% and then 5% with at least 3 profitable days of 0.5% in each phase and no time limit; 1 Step asks for 8% and 3 Step for 3% per phase with no minimum days, OMO for 6% then 8% within 180 days, and the FAQ gives 1 to 3 business days of review after a standard pass, before KYC.
Drawdown model3.22 Step Standard has a 4% daily and an 8% static maximum loss and 2 Step Nano 3% and 10% static; the 1 Step plans and Instant Standard trail 6% and Instant Starter 5% until that profit is reached; Guardian Shield usually closes funded Standard trades at a 2% floating loss and instant ones at 1%, and cuts the split.3.1Standard 2 Step and OMO use a 4% daily limit from the higher of balance or equity and a static 8% maximum, but 1 Step trails 5% from the highest equity, 3 Step allows 2% and 3%, Instant trails 3% with a 1% open-loss limit, and the Account Saver of OMO and funded Buy Now Pay Later cuts the split to 50% at a 2% open loss.
Rule restrictions2.8The help centre allows news trading in evaluations and on Instant Starter and removes profit from trades within 5 minutes of high-impact news on funded and Instant Standard accounts; the plan articles set a 2-minute minimum hold and allow own EAs and weekend holding, and arbitrage bots and hedging across accounts are banned.2.1EAs and automated trading are prohibited, standard plans forbid trades on affected instruments 2 minutes either side of Red Folder news, and grid trading and cross-account hedging are banned; weekend holding and VPNs are allowed, and outside Prediction Markets half of all trades must last 60 seconds and you may copy your own trades manually.
Pricing fairness3.0The help centre refunds the CFD evaluation fee in full after the fourth payout for accounts bought from 21 January 2026, except Instant Starter and accounts hard-breached before it, while the refund policy says no refunds are accepted once the credentials have been emailed.3.6The pricing page shows a price per plan and size, Buy Now Pay Later starts with an entry fee and charges the activation fee after a pass, add-ons are chosen at checkout, and the terms refund the fee, add-ons included, after the third paid reward on every plan but Instant Mini, although the FAQ's list of such plans leaves out Prediction Markets.
Profit split3.2The help centre gives Standard plans 85% (90% with an add-on), 1 Step Nano 85% and 2 Step Nano 80% (each 100% with an add-on), Buy Now Pay Later 80%, Instant Standard 80% (90%) and Instant Starter 90%; a first Guardian Shield trigger cuts it to 50% for good, and the sales pages give up to 90%, 95% or 100%.3.5The standard share is 80% on Standard, OMO, Instant and Buy Now Pay Later accounts and 70% on Instant Mini and Prediction Markets; an add-on raises it to 90% on Standard, OMO, Instant and Instant Mini, and a first Account Saver trigger on OMO or funded Buy Now Pay Later cuts it to 50% for the rest of the account.
Scaling programme0.8No page describes a scaling plan for CFD accounts: the CFD plans collection lists seven rules articles and none on scaling, and the Standard, Nano and instant plan articles describe none, although the how-it-works page speaks of opportunities to grow your account size.0.8The terms, the FAQ, the pricing page and the standard and instant challenge pages describe no scaling plan; funded accounts of the same plan, except Instant Mini, can be merged up to a set combined balance where merging is offered.
Payout reliability2.3The help centre pays Standard plans every 14 days (7 with an add-on), Nano plans every 7 or 14 days, and Instant Standard and Buy Now Pay Later on demand after 5 profitable days, some with caps, with a 3% fee on every payout and processing within 24 business hours; sales pages speak of 7-day payouts and a 1- or 4-hour average.2.1Standard and OMO accounts can request a payout 10 business days after the first trade of each cycle, Instant and Buy Now Pay Later accounts on demand, and on Standard, Instant and BNPL accounts profit above a trader-wide cap per two payouts or 30 days is removed; the risk disclosure puts a successful withdrawal below 2.5% per transaction.
Firm safety2.7The footer names Blue Guardian Limited of Saint Lucia for the simulated platforms and Iconic Exchange FZCO of Dubai for education and payments, the terms are Iconic Exchange's with arbitration in Dubai, the about page names Sean Bainton as CEO, and the footer and help centre call CFD accounts demo accounts, the terms a live account.2.8The terms name MAVEN EDU - FZCO, a Dubai free zone company with trade licence 60823, under UAE law, and the home page's footer also names Maventrade LTD of Saint Lucia without its role; its CEO, CMO, CCO and COO are named, the firm says it has operated since 2022, and the terms claim no financial licence and call all balances simulated.
Transparency1.5The help centre has a rules article for each CFD plan, but the pages disagree on whether funded accounts are live, payout speed and cycle, the top profit share, the fee refund, education and the address of Iconic Exchange FZCO.2.3The terms are versioned with an effective date and product schedules, but the day-trading rules say a flagged account must rerun the challenge and an EA prevents a pass, where the FAQ and terms say termination; those rules also speak of a live account, the FAQ's refund list omits Prediction Markets, and the home page says "instant payouts".
Execution quality2.7CFD accounts trade on MetaTrader 5, Match Trader or TradeLocker (US clients only the last two), with a commission per lot on forex and commodities and none on indices and crypto, forex leverage of 1:50 (1:30 on instant accounts) and a 100% stop-out, but spreads vary and no spread table is published.2.9Forex and CFD traders use MT5 or Match Trader with Match-Prime as the data feed broker, variable spreads shown on test accounts, a commission per lot on each side and no swaps on any plan; currencies get 1:75 leverage, commodities and indices 1:20 and gold 1:100 on OMO only, and the terms call all trading simulated.
Customer support2.8The help centre names live chat and email, with Discord for community questions, and the forex page tickets, Discord and email with 24/7 support, while the contact page gives operational hours of Monday to Friday, 9 am to 5 pm (GST); no phone number of the firm is given.2.7Support runs through Discord, a contact form, email and two phone numbers in the footer, and the site comes in English, Spanish and Portuguese; the contact page says "We're always here to help" but gives no hours and shows the number 0000000000 under its headquarters address.

How we score

What it costs

Differences only
Blue GuardianMaven Trading
Cost to get funded$463$22 (better)
Entry fee$463$22
Advertised account size$100,000$5,000
Quoted currencyNot verifiedUSD
Checkout offering2 Step Standard 100KNot verified

Rules at a glance

Blue GuardianMaven Trading
Maximum loss8% · static8% · static
Evaluation steps2 steps2 steps
Daily loss limit4%4%
Drawdown typeStaticStatic
Profit target phase 1 pct8%8%
Profit target phase 2 pct4%5%
PlatformMT5Not verified
Market typeCFDsForex
Payout clockNot verifiedYour first payout is available 10 business days after your first trade on the Simulated Funded Account. Each subsequent 10-business-day period starts with your first trade after the previous payout.

Payouts and fees

Blue GuardianMaven Trading
Profit split85% (better)80%
First payout14 days10 days · business days
Profit split conditionsIf your open trades reach a combined 2% floating loss, Guardian Shield will usually close all open trades. You can keep trading straight away, but there are consequences: 1st time: your profit split drops to 50% permanently. 2nd time: the account is permanently breached.Not verified
First payout qualifying daysNot verified3 qualifying days
Payout interval days14 calendar daysNot verified
Payout scheduleNot verified10 business days
Payout cap conditionsNot verifiedFor Standard 1 Step, Standard 2 Step, Standard 3 Step, Buy Now Pay Later and Instant Funding Simulated Funded Accounts, a maximum of $10,000 before the reward split may be withdrawn across two payouts or within any rolling 30-day period.
Payout conditionsWhen: once you've met the minimum trading days and 14 days have passed since your first trade, then every 14 days after your previous request. With the 7-day payout add-on, it's every 7 days. Conditions: account above starting balance, no rule violations and all positions closed.You need at least 3 profitable days in each evaluation phase and 3 new profitable days for each funded payout cycle. Each qualifying day must earn at least 0.5% of the initial account balance. The days do not need to be consecutive.

Compare with